Steakhouses in Columbus

At The Capital Grille in Columbus, Ohio, you'll step into a world that feels both luxurious and reminiscent of an old-school steakhouse. The ambiance is undeniably romantic and upscale, perfect for those special occasions like anniversaries or date nights, though some might find it a bit too formal. The mood lighting adds to the intimate atmosphere, making it a great spot for a memorable evening. The service here is top-notch, with a knowledgeable staff and an extensive wine list to guide you through your meal. Valet parking is available, adding a touch of convenience to your dining experience. The steaks are the star of the show, with the filet mignon and ribeye being standout choices, often described as tender and perfectly cooked. However, be aware that a few diners have mentioned experiencing tough or overcooked steaks. For seafood lovers, the lobster dishes and crab cakes come highly recommended, though one review noted a less favorable experience with the lobster bisque. If you're in the mood for a cocktail, the dirty martini is a hit, though the quality of other cocktails can vary. And don't skip out on dessert; the chocolate espresso cake is a sweet way to end your meal.

At Johnny's Italian Steakhouse in Columbus, Ohio, you'll find a mixed bag of experiences. The ambiance is a bit of a rollercoaster; the bar area feels like a cute, secluded oasis with phenomenal lighting, but the dining area can feel drab and even depressing, reminiscent of a hotel waiting room. While some folks rave about it as a fine dining spot perfect for special occasions like birthdays or anniversaries, others are quick to point out slow service, inconsistent food quality, and management issues that don't quite meet those high expectations. As for features, there's a mention of a happy hour, but you might want to double-check its existence. Brunch gets mixed reviews too, with some enjoying a Saturday spread while others complain about availability, food quality, and service. And if you're sensitive to smoke, be aware that one review mentioned a bartender smelling of cigarette smoke, though it's unclear if smoking is allowed. Desserts seem to be a highlight, with the lemoncello cake and warm chocolate cake getting praise for being rich, massive, and bursting with flavor. On the drink front, opinions on martinis and cocktails are all over the place, with some enjoying them while others find them overpriced or off in flavor. Steak lovers, brace yourselves for inconsistency. The ribeye has fans who call it the best ever, perfectly cooked and seasoned, but others have found it overcooked, cold, or lacking flavor. The filet mignon is just okay according to one review, and the prime rib is a definite no-go with overwhelmingly negative feedback. On a brighter note, the beef wellington gets a thumbs up. If you're into seafood, the lobster mac and cheese has its fans, but watch out for overcooked or watery dishes. Crab dishes are hit or miss, with one review praising the crab cake despite its small size, while another found the crab overcooked. Overall, Johnny's Italian Steakhouse offers a mixed dining experience that might be worth trying if you're in the mood for a gamble.

At The Lounge at Final Cut in Columbus, Ohio, the ambiance is a mixed bag; some of us found it beautifully sophisticated with soft music, while others felt it resembled a business hotel restaurant more than a romantic spot for anniversary dinners. The steakhouse markets itself as high-end, but the inconsistent quality of food and service leaves us questioning if it truly meets fine-dining standards. As for features, there's a hint of a movie star theme with costumes on display, though it's not a consistent or central element of the experience. When it comes to steaks, opinions are all over the place; the filet mignon and ribeye have received both praise and criticism, with some steaks being tender and others disappointingly overcooked or bland. On the dessert front, the chocolate cake has been a letdown for many, often described as bland or too simple. Drink-wise, the cocktails are pricey but considered worthwhile by some patrons. Overall, while The Lounge at Final Cut has its charms, the inconsistency in food quality and service makes it a gamble for a special occasion.

Butcher & Rose in Columbus, Ohio, offers a top-notch dining experience that's perfect for special occasions. The ambiance is elegant yet inviting, with a romantic and sophisticated vibe that makes it a great spot for date nights or celebrations. The service is exceptional, with staff who are attentive, knowledgeable, and eager to make your meal memorable. The steaks are a highlight, with options like ribeye, filet, and Wagyu that are consistently cooked to perfection and praised for their tenderness and flavor. The menu also features standout dishes like Beef Wellington, which has received high marks for its quality and presentation. For those looking for more than just steak, the seafood offerings, including lobster bisque and sea bass, are also highly recommended. The sides, such as potatoes Anna and creamed spinach, complement the main courses well, adding to the overall dining experience. Desserts like crème brûlée and cheesecake are popular choices to end your meal on a sweet note. The drink menu is impressive, with a wide selection of wines and creatively crafted cocktails that enhance the dining experience. Overall, Butcher & Rose is a must-visit for anyone seeking a high-end dining experience in Columbus. Whether you're celebrating a special occasion or just looking for a memorable meal, this steakhouse delivers on all fronts.

Mitchell's Steakhouse in Columbus, Ohio offers a mixed dining experience. The ambiance varies from elegant and upscale to sometimes quiet and muted, depending on the location and time of visit. The steaks, a highlight for many, are generally well-received with some diners raving about their tenderness and flavor, though others have noted inconsistencies in cooking and quality. The seafood dishes, like lobster bisque and spicy lobster, have received mixed reviews, with some finding them delicious and others disappointed with the preparation. Side dishes and appetizers can be hit or miss, with some standouts like truffle fries, but also complaints about overcooked or underwhelming options. The service is often praised for being friendly and attentive, though there have been instances of slow service and inattentiveness. Overall, Mitchell's Steakhouse can offer a great dining experience, but it's worth noting that experiences can vary, so setting expectations accordingly might enhance your visit.

At Ruth's Chris Steak House in Columbus, Ohio, the ambiance is often described as classy, elegant, and perfect for a romantic dinner or special occasion. The dim, soft lighting adds to the upscale and sophisticated atmosphere, though some find it a bit gloomy. As a fine dining spot, expect a dress code and higher prices, but be aware that service and food quality can be inconsistent at times. They offer a happy hour with special menu items, though the online menu might not always be up-to-date and prices can change unexpectedly. Valet parking is available, but it was once unavailable due to COVID-19. The steaks, including filet mignon and ribeye, receive mixed reviews; some diners praise their tenderness and flavor, while others find them tough or overcooked. If you're looking for seafood, the lobster dishes are generally well-received, though the lobster mac and cheese might lack flavor. Crab dishes, like crab cakes, have mixed feedback, with some enjoying them and others finding them dry or overcooked. Overall, Ruth's Chris can be a great choice for a special night out, but be prepared for potential inconsistencies in the dining experience.

Mitchell's Steakhouse in Columbus, Ohio, offers a mixed dining experience. The ambiance is generally praised for being quiet and conducive to conversation, with a cozy and upscale feel that's great for special occasions. However, some diners have noted a discrepancy between the advertised dress code and the actual attire of patrons, which can detract from the upscale atmosphere. The steakhouse features a variety of unique elements, including live music on the patio and a vibrant happy hour scene. The happy hour is particularly popular, offering a range of appetizing bites and drinks at reasonable prices, making it a great spot to unwind after work. Desserts at Mitchell's are a highlight for many, with large portions and delicious flavors, especially the chocolate cake which is often mentioned as a must-try. The drink menu is well-regarded, with a selection of well-made cocktails and a respectable wine and champagne list. The happy hour drinks are a standout, with favorites like margaritas and mojitos being praised for their fresh ingredients and classic recipes. Steaks are a focal point at Mitchell's, with the filet mignon being a popular choice. While many enjoy the tenderness and flavor of the steaks, there have been complaints about inconsistent cooking temperatures and a lack of seasoning on some occasions. The ribeye and New York strip also receive mixed reviews, with some diners finding them dry or overcooked. Seafood options, such as the lobster bisque and spicy lobster, are generally well-received, with many appreciating the creamy texture and rich flavors. The crab cake is another favorite, noted for its generous portion and fresh taste. Sides at Mitchell's can be hit or miss. The jalapeño scalloped potatoes are a standout, often described as delicious and spicy, while other sides like the macaroni and cheese and Brussels sprouts receive varied feedback, with some finding them bland and others enjoying their unique flavors. Overall, Mitchell's Steakhouse offers a fine dining experience with some standout dishes and a lively happy hour, but consistency in food quality and service could be improved to meet the expectations set by its upscale atmosphere and pricing.

At Ted's Montana Grill in Columbus, Ohio, the ambiance strikes a perfect balance between relaxing, cozy, and upscale, with an old-school steakhouse vibe that's ideal for a romantic date night. The lighting is dim, adding to the intimate atmosphere without being overly dark. While the prices might be on the higher side, the experience feels more casual-upscale than traditional fine dining. Happy hour is a highlight, featuring tasty burgers and nachos that are perfect for a more laid-back visit. The steaks here are a major draw, with the filet mignon and ribeye receiving high praise for their tenderness and flavor, often described as melting in your mouth. However, it's worth noting that some diners have experienced issues with steaks being overcooked or dry. On the drink menu, the cocktails shine, especially the margaritas, which are frequently described as delicious, the best ever, and even spicy. If you're in the mood for seafood, the crab cakes come highly recommended and are a must-try side dish. Overall, Ted's Montana Grill offers a memorable dining experience that combines great food with a welcoming atmosphere.

At The Avenue Steak Tavern in Columbus, Ohio, you'll step into a world that feels like 1920s New York, with an ambiance that's upscale, romantic, and intimate. The dim lighting adds to the classic feel, though it can get a bit crowded and noisy at times. While the restaurant aims for a fine dining experience, some diners feel the price doesn't quite match the experience. It's a great spot for a date night, and the background music sets a nice mood, though it can be a bit loud for some. They offer a happy hour with great deals on cocktails and appetizers, and there's a sommelier on hand to help with wine choices. Brunch is available, but opinions on it are mixed, with some wishing it was offered more often. The steaks here are a highlight, especially the filet mignon, which is often described as tender and delicious. However, the ribeye and porterhouse have received mixed reviews, with some finding them bland or not cooked to their liking. If you're into seafood, the lobster, particularly the twin lobster tails, gets positive feedback. The cocktails are highly recommended, with many praising their taste and presentation, though experiences with specific drinks like martinis and margaritas vary. For dessert, the chocolate cake is a popular choice, sometimes even offered complimentary.